Assessing the Chinese language View of India


Geographical divide

India and China have been neighbors for over 4000 years. One can say that that they had been residing collectively like two dormant dinosaurs because the daybreak of historical past. One purpose for this was the Himalayan mountain vary that fashioned an impregnable barrier between the 2 international locations. The second purpose was the existence of a buffer state in Tibet. Although China had all the time claimed Tibet as its integral half but for important intervals in historical past Tibet was an unbiased state. Thus an efficient buffer existed between China and India. The Tibetan plateau can be pretty forbidding and geographically and bodily was not one of the best ways to succeed in India.

Regardless of nice dynasties just like the Mughal in India and the Ming in China folks to folks contact between the Chinese language and Indians was close to zero. Regardless of this, the unfold of Buddhist faith did happen regardless of the Himalayan barrier. This intermingling of thought resulted within the unfold of Buddhist philosophy from India.


The Buddha was a unifying issue between the relations between India and China. The arrival of the 20th century noticed a thaw between India and China contacts. Fashionable expertise and revolutionary thought contributed to India and China changing into neighbors with a border unfold over virtually three thousand kilometers. China thus appeared on the doorstep of India. This was as a result of defective insurance policies adopted by Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru who gave up Tibet as a buffer state. This by itself is the one largest blunder of Nehru. China additionally started to observe a path of domination with a communist regime taking management of China. Mao Tse Tung started to work to revive the outdated glory of China which at one time was thought-about the ‘center kingdom‘ and the middle of the world.

Indian management

In distinction, the Indian management was extra like a tortoise content material to reside from daily and having completely incorrect priorities. Pandit Nehru was speaking of imperialism which had turn into a lifeless horse after world warfare II. The Chinese language have been additionally on the receiving finish however they have been in a position to pull by with their imaginative and prescient to dominate the world.

The Indian folks led by Nehru and Gandhi wished to reside their life in their very own sphere of affect. Domination of Asia and a hark again to historical Hindu Kings who dominated South and Central Asia was by no means the beacon. This was maybe the result of 900 years of Muslim rule.

Nonetheless, by its very measurement regardless of a whole lack of ambition to dominate Asia the Chinese language have been alarmed. India as a possible nice energy sooner or later just isn’t acceptable to China which sees India as a rival. One should keep in mind that if one needs to see his personal picture one has to look right into a mirror. The reflection will present you what you actually appear like. Retaining this in thoughts it’s worthwhile to know as to how India’s largest competitor China seems to be at India.


Many readers would have heard and skim the writings of the well-known Indian political commentator and thinker Chanakya who lived round 340 BC. He was instrumental within the rise of Samrat Chandragupta who defeated the Greeks and consolidated a large empire over most of India and prolonged to Central Asia.

This was doable due to the recommendation of Chanakya. His writings have come down to the current age and have relevance within the 21st century. Chanakya has said that to defeat the enemy one should understand how he thinks and plans for you. Therefore the Chinese language level of India have to be a part of the menu of each Indian mental and politician. We additionally should keep in mind that China thinks of India as a competitor. There’s a good likelihood that what the Chinese language take into consideration India is absolutely their dream however generally desires can turn into a actuality and thus it’s worthwhile to look at what the Chinese language consider India.

There are two opinions to this line of thought. The primary one is to dismiss the Chinese language standpoint as mere rhetoric however the second is to recollect what Chanakya had mentioned. He has articulated nation must not ever dismiss the enemies assessments out of hand. Therefore what the Chinese language consider India and what’s their line of thought is one thing that we should examine.

Chinese language view

The Chinese language Institute of strategic research has compiled an article which was revealed just a few years again. Later the Chinese language authorities and the institute itself backtracked from this text and claimed it didn’t signify their official coverage. Regardless of this denial, the article gave the Chinese language view of India. It’s price analyzing what this text says.

The students from the Institute’s assume tank opine that India is ripe for disintegration, like what occurred to the erstwhile Soviet Union. At the moment the coverage of glasnost ushered in by Mikhail Gorbachev noticed the united states break up into 18 international locations and the People have been completely delighted.

The Chinese language really feel that one of many tips that could the disintegration of India is the Hindu faith itself. This thought shouldn’t be dismissed out of hand. China says that the caste system that exists in India does not exist wherever on the planet. That is true. The Chinese language additionally say that this caste system is perpetrated by the federal government and is a part of the Indian Structure which sanctifies the division of society right into a caste-based society. This once more to an extent is true. Thus for the following two or three generations, there isn’t a hope that the caste division of Hindu society can finish. There isn’t any doubt this caste system runs deep within the nation and it’s on file that the assorted elections within the nation present a division of society on caste.

Countering China

Gandhi’s failure

Mahatma Gandhi had a great opportunity to get rid of the caste system. he had a grip on the plenty however sadly, Gandhi made no try on this course. He has gone on file and mentioned that the caste system was good for Hinduism. He additionally mentioned that equality amongst castes doesn’t imply decrease caste will sit and eat meals on the identical desk with the upper caste. Many individuals are usually not conscious that when Gandhi held his well-known speeches on caste within the nation, he allowed separate enclosures to be created for the scheduled caste and the untouchables. Why the decrease castes have been separated has by no means been defined by anyone.

One can not actually agree 100% with what the Chinese language assume tank is publishing however the reality stays that caste, as sanctified within the structure, just isn’t a wholesome signal of for a rustic aspiring to throw the previous shackles off.


One other bugbear is the.creation of linguistic states in India. That is detrimental to the mixing of the nation. India was by no means divided into linguistic strains all through its historical past. The creation of linguistic States actually hits on the roots of an built-in India. The RSS which at one time opposed the idea of linguistic States and caste-based reservation has modified its tune and that is by itself could be very detrimental to the state.

As well as, we now have an insurgency in six States led by the Maoists and a low-intensity warfare is on in Kashmir and the Northeast, notably the tribal areas of Japanese India. The military must be deployed for this low-grade army exercise. The Indian nation can not afford to withdraw the military from these areas as withdrawal of the military from these areas will result in secession from the republic and that would properly be the tip of India. The military is thus the most important stakeholder within the unity of India.

The military can’t be the only real power to unite India, the politicians must play the ball as properly. Nonetheless, caste and faith, coupled with linguist division of India just isn’t the most effective recipe for the Indian nation. As well as, far-flung areas like Kashmir and the Northeast haven’t been built-in with the mom nation and we have now anachronisms like article 370 and reservation primarily based on caste. This interprets to a rustic the place 50% of all jobs are reserved on the premise of caste and meritocracy is given a low seat. That is one thing that can not be championed by anyone, but there isn’t a one to bell this lethal concoction. At finest all these elements can disturb the most effective of intellectuals.

Final phrase

The Indian management could have some introspection to do. The Chinese language view is the most important bugbear to the unity of India. The Hindu faith itself which relies on caste and untouchability must reform. Indian intellectuals must look in phrases and counter this opinion of the Chinese language institute. It isn’t vital that the Chinese language view might be a actuality as a result of India has the capability to get out of this lavatory.

There isn’t any doubt that the Chinese language live on a wishful hope. It is usually price remembering that two swords don’t match a scabbard and China can by no means be a good friend of India, however by no means the much less the Chinese language view may additionally prevail.

Leave a Comment

Share via
Copy link